This creamy tomato soup with grilled cheese for two is the dinner for cold, gray evenings when nothing else will do. The soup starts with one big can of tomatoes, simmers with onion, garlic and a little basil, then gets blended silky smooth and finished with just enough cream. While it simmers, two cheddar grilled cheese sandwiches turn golden in a skillet next to it. Dunk, repeat.
Everything is ready in under 30 minutes, and it costs less than almost any takeout.
Canned Tomatoes Beat Fresh in November
It sounds backward, but for tomato soup outside of late summer, canned tomatoes are the better choice. Tomatoes for canning are picked ripe and packed within hours, so they're sweet, deep red and full of flavor. The fresh ones in the store in winter are usually picked green and taste mostly of water.
Look for whole peeled tomatoes rather than diced. Diced tomatoes are often treated with calcium chloride so the pieces hold their shape, which also stops them from breaking down into a smooth soup. Whole tomatoes collapse easily as they simmer. Crush them with a wooden spoon right in the pot.
One 28-ounce can makes two generous bowls, so there's no half-can left over in the fridge.
Tomato Paste and a Pinch of Sugar
Two small additions make a big difference. A spoonful of tomato paste, cooked for a minute with the onion and garlic until it darkens a shade, adds a deeper, slightly roasted tomato flavor that canned tomatoes alone don't have.
The half teaspoon of sugar isn't there to make the soup sweet. Canned tomatoes can be quite acidic, and that sharpness gets stronger when cream is added. A pinch of sugar rounds it off. If your tomatoes are already sweet, you can leave it out. Taste after the simmer and decide.
Blending Hot Soup Safely
An immersion blender is the easiest tool here. You blend right in the pot with no transferring and almost no mess. Take the pot off the heat first, keep the blender head fully under the surface so it doesn't splash, and blend for about a minute until completely smooth.
A countertop blender works too, but hot soup needs care. Steam builds up inside a closed blender and can push the lid off. Fill the jar no more than halfway, remove the small center cap from the lid, cover the hole with a folded kitchen towel, and start on the lowest speed. Then pour the soup back into the pot.
How Much Cream Is Enough?
This soup uses one-third of a cup, enough to make it velvety and soften the acidity without hiding the tomato. Stir it in after blending, over low heat, and warm it for just a minute. Don't let the soup boil once the cream is in. Acid and high heat together can make cream separate into little specks.
Half-and-half works if that's what you have; the soup will just be a little lighter. For a dairy-free bowl, full-fat coconut milk is a surprisingly good stand-in.
The Grilled Cheese Rules
A great grilled cheese has a crisp, deep-golden outside and fully melted cheese inside, and the secret to both is low heat. Over medium-high, the bread burns before the cheese has a chance to melt.
- Butter the bread, not the pan. Spread soft butter right to the edges of each slice for even browning.
- Use sharp cheddar, shredded or thinly sliced. Thin pieces melt faster than thick slabs, and sharp cheddar holds its own against the tangy soup.
- Go medium-low and be patient. About 3 to 4 minutes per side.
- Use a lid. Covering the skillet for the first side traps heat and melts the cheese before the bread gets too dark.
Sturdy sandwich bread or sourdough is best, since it holds up to dunking without falling apart.
Timing Both So Nothing Gets Cold
The order is simple: start the soup first. Once the tomatoes are in and simmering, you have 10 minutes, which is exactly enough to butter the bread and cook both sandwiches. Take the sandwiches off the heat, blend the soup, stir in the cream, and everything reaches the table hot at the same time.
Making Creamy Tomato Soup with Grilled Cheese for Two Your Own
Once you have the basic version down, it's easy to change things up:
- Roasted red pepper: add a few jarred roasted red peppers with the tomatoes for a sweeter, smokier soup.
- Pesto swirl: a spoonful of basil pesto on top of each bowl adds fresh, herby flavor.
- Different cheese: try Gruyère with a little Dijon on the bread, or mozzarella with a few basil leaves.
- A bit of heat: a pinch of red pepper flakes in the soup or a few slices of pickled jalapeño in the sandwich.
Freezing the Soup
Tomato soup freezes very well, as long as you freeze it before adding the cream. Let it cool, freeze it in an airtight container for up to 3 months, then thaw it in the fridge overnight, reheat it gently and stir in the cream at the end. If you've already added the cream, the soup still keeps in the fridge for up to 4 days. Reheat it slowly over low heat. Grilled cheese is best made fresh.
My favorite way to serve this is with the sandwiches cut into strips instead of triangles, because they're much easier to dunk. On colder nights, I add a few leaves of fresh basil to the soup right before blending. And a few cracks of black pepper over each bowl makes it look as good as it tastes.







