Lobster Tails for Two

Be the first to rate

Two lobster tails butterflied so the sweet meat sits on top of the shell, brushed with garlic lemon butter and broiled until just opaque. Ready in about 25 minutes, they make an elegant Christmas or date-night dinner for two.

Two broiled lobster tails with garlic lemon butter on a blue and white platter
Prep15 mins
Cook10 mins
Total25 mins
Servings2
Jump to Nutrition Facts270 calories per serving
In this post
  1. Buying Lobster Tails
  2. Thawing Them the Right Way
  3. Butterflying, Step by Step
  4. Why Broil?
  5. Opaque, Not Rubbery
  6. Garlic Butter, Twice
  7. Lobster Tails for Two on a Special Night
  8. What to Serve With Lobster
  9. Leftovers
  10. The recipe

These lobster tails for two look like something from a fancy seafood restaurant, but they take about 25 minutes at home. Each tail is butterflied so the sweet, tender meat sits up on top of its shell, brushed with garlic lemon butter, and broiled for just a few minutes until it turns opaque and lightly golden. A final spoonful of butter and a squeeze of lemon, and dinner is ready.

Buying Lobster Tails

Most lobster tails sold in grocery stores come frozen, and that's perfectly fine. Look for tails that are 6 to 8 ounces each, which is a generous serving for one person. Smaller tails cook too fast and can dry out under the broiler.

You'll often see two kinds. Cold-water tails, from places like Maine or Canada, have sweeter, more tender meat and are usually a bit more expensive. Warm-water tails, often from the Caribbean or Florida, are larger and firmer but can taste a little less sweet. Both work in this recipe. Choose tails with clean, white meat and no gray or yellow spots.

Thawing Them the Right Way

Frozen lobster tails need to be fully thawed before cooking, or the outside will overcook while the middle is still icy. The best way is overnight in the fridge on a plate.

If you forgot, seal the tails in a zip-top bag and set them in a bowl of cold water for 30 to 60 minutes, changing the water once. Never use warm water or the microwave. Both start cooking the delicate meat unevenly and make it tough.

Butterflying, Step by Step

Butterflying sounds tricky, but it only takes a minute per tail and gives that classic restaurant look:

  1. With kitchen shears, cut down the center of the top shell, from the wide end toward the tail fin. Stop just before the fin.
  2. Gently spread the shell open with your thumbs.
  3. Slide your fingers under the meat to loosen it from the bottom shell, keeping it attached at the tail end.
  4. Lift the meat up through the cut so it rests on top of the closed shell.
  5. Remove the dark vein if there is one, and make a shallow cut along the top of the meat so it lies flat.

Why Broil?

The broiler cooks lobster tails fast from above, which is exactly what they need. The top of the meat turns lightly golden in a few minutes while the inside stays tender and juicy. Baking takes longer and can dry out the edges, and boiling washes away the butter and makes the meat waterlogged.

Set an oven rack about 6 inches below the broiler and let it heat fully before the tails go in. A cast-iron skillet holds the tails steady and catches every drop of butter. Remember the handle gets very hot under the broiler, so use an oven mitt every time you touch it.

Opaque, Not Rubbery

Lobster goes from tender to rubbery quickly, so watch it closely. It's done when the meat has turned from glassy and translucent to bright white and opaque all the way through, usually 6 to 8 minutes for 6 to 8 ounce tails.

An instant-read thermometer takes out the guessing. Insert it into the thickest part of the meat. Lobster is done at about 140°F (60°C). Take it out as soon as it gets there, because it keeps cooking for a moment in the hot pan.

Garlic Butter, Twice

The garlic lemon butter goes on in two stages. First, brush a little over the meat before it goes under the broiler. It helps the top brown and seasons the lobster as it cooks. Then, right after the tails come out, spoon the rest over the top. The warm butter melts into every crevice and keeps the meat glossy and moist.

Finely minced garlic works best here. Bigger pieces can scorch under the broiler and taste bitter.

Lobster Tails for Two on a Special Night

Lobster tails are made for Christmas Eve, New Year's Eve, an anniversary or Valentine's Day. They feel luxurious but take very little hands-on time, so you can enjoy the evening instead of standing at the stove.

For a classic surf and turf, serve one lobster tail each alongside our filet mignon for two. Both cook in a similar amount of time, so you can sear the steaks first, let them rest, and broil the lobster while they wait.

What to Serve With Lobster

Keep the sides simple so the lobster stays the star. Roasted asparagus or green beans, a crisp green salad with lemon vinaigrette, buttery baby potatoes or a little rice pilaf all work well. Warm crusty bread is perfect for any leftover butter.

A chilled Chardonnay or a glass of sparkling wine is a classic pairing. Sparkling water with lemon works just as well.

Leftovers

If any lobster is left, take it out of the shell and keep it in the fridge for up to 2 days. Cold lobster makes an excellent lobster roll. Toss it with a little mayonnaise, lemon and chives and pile it into a toasted, buttered roll. Reheated lobster tends to turn tough, so serving it cold is usually the best choice.

Love this? Save it for later!

Save to Pinterest
Close-up of butterflied lobster tails for two with garlic butter and lemon

Equipment

  • 10-inch enameled cast-iron or cast-iron skillet

Ingredients

Servings2

For the lobster

  • 2 lobster tails (6 to 8 oz / 170 to 225 g each), thawed if frozen
  • 1/8 teaspoon salt
  • Pinch of black pepper
  • 1/4 teaspoon paprika

For the garlic lemon butter

  • 3 tablespoons (42 g) unsalted butter
  • 2 garlic cloves, very finely minced
  • 1 teaspoon fresh lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon chopped fresh parsley
  • Lemon wedges, for serving

Instructions

  1. Step 1

    Set an oven rack about 6 inches (15 cm) below the broiler and heat the broiler to high.

  2. Step 2

    With kitchen shears, cut down the center of the top shell of each tail, stopping just before the tail fin. Spread the shell open, loosen the meat from the bottom shell and lift it up so it rests on top of the shell. Remove any dark vein and make a shallow cut along the top of the meat.

  3. Step 3

    Melt the butter in a small bowl in the microwave, about 30 seconds. Stir in the garlic and lemon juice.

  4. Step 4

    Set the tails in a 10-inch cast-iron skillet. Season the meat with the salt, pepper and paprika, and brush with about one-third of the garlic butter.

  5. Step 5

    Broil for 6 to 8 minutes, until the meat is opaque all the way through and reaches 140°F (60°C) in the thickest part.

  6. Step 6

    Using an oven mitt, take the skillet out. Spoon the rest of the garlic butter over the lobster, sprinkle with the parsley and serve right away with lemon wedges.

Tips & notes

My first tails came out perfect on top but slightly undercooked in the thickest part, because the meat was piled up too high. Now I make the shallow cut along the top so it sits flatter and cooks evenly. I also check them at 5 minutes, since every broiler runs a little differently.

  • Bigger tails: For 10 to 12 oz (285 to 340 g) tails, broil 10 to 12 minutes and go by the thermometer.
  • Dipping butter: Melt an extra 2 tablespoons (28 g) of butter with a squeeze of lemon to serve on the side.
  • On the grill: Grill butterflied tails meat side down over medium-high heat for 5 minutes, flip and baste with the butter, then grill 4 to 5 minutes more.

Nutrition Facts

Per serving (estimate)

Calories270
Total Fat18 g
Carbohydrates2 g
Fiber0 g
Sugars0 g
Protein25 g
Sodium780 mg

Nutrition information is an estimate based on the ingredients used and may vary. See our Disclaimer.

Get easy dinners for two in your inbox

New recipes and simple dinner ideas sized for two, straight to your inbox. It's free.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy

Share this Print
Hailey Brooks

Written by

Hailey Brooks

Hailey is the founder of Easy Dinner Ideas for Two and a home cook who learned her way around the kitchen from her grandmother Dorothy, who once ran a small restaurant. Cooking for herself and her husband James, Hailey creates dinners sized for two that cut c…

More about Hailey Brooks →

Ratings & Comments

No ratings yet. Be the first!
Your rating

Comments appear after a quick review.